Add Your Podcast | Feedback/Suggestions | Search |
Podcasting News Home | Audio & Music News | Articles | Podcast Directory | Forum | Podcasting Gear | Podcasting Gear Manufacturers |
![]()
« Sub Pop Records Says Podcast Our Music, Before We Change Our Mind | Main | California Governor Schwarzenegger - Podcastinator? »5 Myths of Podcasting: Myth 2 - Podcasters are Wacky and UnprofessionalJune 07, 2005Commentary: Elle Webb It seems like every mainstream discussion of podcasting has to start with a mention of how unprofessional some shows sound, how somebody records their show while they bike or drive to work, how people are podcasting in their pajamas or how some podcasters ramble on about nothing. There's an element of truth to all this - there are thousands of podcasts, and most of them are put together by amateurs. Many of these are poorly produced, or self-indulgent. These podcasts, though, are in no way representative of podcasting as a whole. They are representative of the idea that 90% of just about anything is garbage. In reality, most popular podcasts are fairly well-produced. Top podcasts, like Adam Curry's, Weekend America, or NASA's, have similar production values to traditional radio shows. Some of the earliest "breakout" podcasts feature personalities that spew colorful language and views. The poster child for this has been Dawn Miceli, whose wit and irreverent views have helped make the Dawn and Drew Show an early podcasting hit. While some may view podcasters discussing controversial topics or speaking with obscenities as wacky or unprofessional, is it any different than Bill O'Reilly or Rush Limbaugh playing fast and loose with facts, or Howard Stern "sexing up" his show with salacious talk? One of the defining features of podcasting is that it's a world free of many of the rules of traditional broadcasting. This means the language may be coarser and the subject matter rawer than what you'll hear on traditional radio. None of this is particularly shocking to Net-saavy listeners, though it may surprise those unfamiliar with the freedoms available on the Internet. Another defining feature of podcasting is that technology has driven the cost of producing an Internet audio show down to the point of being insignificant. Anybody with a computer, a mic, an Internet connection, and an idea can make a podcast. If many of the ideas expressed are mundane, it doesn't invalidate the technology or the importance to podcasters of being able to express their ideas. So, don't dismiss podcasters as wacky and unprofessional. The bottom line is, producing a daily or weekly show that is interesting and sounds decent is a lot of work. If you listen to any of the top podcasts, you'll find that they are competently produced, interesting, and feature creative work that might not find a home on traditional radio. And that's not so wacky, after all! CommentsJust like there are bad blogs, there will be bad podcasts. Eventually the good podcasts will grow, and the bad ones won't. The law of supply and demand will eventually weed out the bad podcasts. Posted by: Josh H at June 7, 2005 07:51 AM I think it's fair to say that everyone podcasts at their own level and that each podcast has a core audience whether it be 1500 listeners, like my show gets of unsigned and indie artists and fans (www.craigsmusic.net), or your family and friends who listen to you because they think your so cool. The quality is almost secondary to the enjoyment you get out of recording and publishing your podcast. Posted by: Craig Manganello at June 7, 2005 11:42 AM Podcasting while biking??? Did my show get mentioned in the press??? Where? -jon (the media whore) Posted by: jon at June 7, 2005 10:23 PM bad by whose metrics? By what standards? Thing is podcasting is not replacing radio - it's about doing something totally different to radio so has different production, style and delivery. Sure there is similarity now - but not for long. Podcasting will find it's own voice and might eclipse radio - but it won't do that by copying it; or judging casts by 'radio' production standards. Dawn and Drew aren't particularly well produced - well the first ones really sucked you could hardly hear them both - but it still was captivating. That voice and interest has nothing to do with production values...it's to do with honesty and interest in other people. Posted by: tim @ Radio Clash at June 9, 2005 10:02 PM Post a comment |
|
Copyright 2004-5 Podcasting News